Title:
Be Quiet? Evaluating Proactive and Reactive User Interface Assistants
Authors:
Jun Xiao, Richard Catrambone,
John Stasko
Abstract:
This research examined the ability of an anthropomorphic interface
assistant to help people learn and use an unfamiliar text-editing
tool, with a specific focus on assessing proactive a ssistant
behavior. Participants in the study were introduced to a text
editing system that used keypress c ombinations for invoking the
different editing operations. Participants then were directed to
make a set of pre scribed changes to a document with the aid either
of a paper manual, an interface assistant that would hear and respond
to questions orally, or an assistant that responded to questions and
additionally made proactive sug gestions. Anecdotal evidence
suggested that proactive assistant behavior would not enhance
performance and would be viewed as intrusive. Our results showed
that all three conditions performed similarly on objecti ve editing
performance (completion time, commands issued, and command recall),
while the participants in the l atter two conditions strongly felt
that the assistant's help was valuable.
Keywords: Agent,
intelligent assistant, anthropomorphism, empirical study, text editing,
help, evaluation, interface agent
You can access this
technical report via: PDF