Home Page

Creative Writings


Home Page

A Zen Grading Policy

Idris Hsi, Aug 5, 1996


---------- Forwarded message ----------
Date: Mon, 5 Aug 1996 10:59:33 -0400 (EDT)
From: Idris H. Hsi <idris@cc.gatech.edu>
To: Senior TAs <cs1502-snr@cc.gatech.edu>
Subject: New grading policy for quizzes and finals.

   In the process of grading tests, one will occasionally find one that is
virtually blank with maybe an occasional attempted answer.  Now, if the
grader is feeling compassionate, some attempt might be made to assign
partial credit.

   Usually, an unanswered question is assigned a 0.  However, we can
assume that in order to not answer the question, the student would have
had to have read the question.  That expenditure of effort does show
that the student knows how to read and therefore, a 1/2 point can be
given.

   Now we can also infer from the blank space that the student knew
enough about the question to know that they couldn't answer it.  This
takes some intuition and some baseline knowledge that may be deeply
buried.  Therefore, the grader could assign another 1/2 point, giving the
student the benefit of the doubt, bringing the total up to 1.

   Now everyone knows that true learning begins with ignorance and by
knowing that one does not know.  By leaving the question blank, the
student has acknowledged that they are completely ignorant and have taken
a big step on the way to greater wisdom.  This should earn them at least
half credit.

   If the grader had a good background in Eastern philosophy, then
he/she would know that the greatest expression of Zen thought is mushin
or "no mind."  By leaving the answer (and most of the test) blank, the
student has really shown that they have achieved the highest level of
learning and should be given full credit on all such questions.

   Of course, points will still be taken off for those questions that were
partially and incorrectly answered.

Idris H. Hsi